You are here:Home > All Publishers > Aristotle Circle for Targeted Test Preparation > Review of Aristotle Circle's Material
Some Thoughts From Think Tonight:
Our business is built around providing quality enrichment material for smart children. Since these types of materials teach the skills that are often tested for to determine whether or not children will be accepted into gifted and talented programs and competitive entry programs we found ourselves in the test prep business.

Two types of tests are commonly used for gifted and talented screening. Achievement tests attempt to measure what you know. Does your child know their math facts? Can they read? Ability tests, in contrast, attempt to measure what your child is capable of. What is their potential as a problem solver and learner?

With achievement testing it's been common to use practice tests for review and familiarization. What is being tested is known.

With ability testing the norm has been for the tests to be "protected."
The questions are confidential and there is limited public information about the content of the questions.

In recent years the situation has changed.
When we started our business we were able to honestly tell customers that there were no practice tests on the market for the commonly used ability tests. This has changed in recent years.

The WPPSI-IV, WISC-IV, CogAT, NNAT, OLSAT and others remain protected tests, and there are potential problems if your child has been prepared specifically for the testing but, driven by the incredible competitiveness in New York City to get into both public Gifted and Talented programs and private schools, tutoring companies started to publish test specific workbooks. These vary from rubbish with obvious English grammar and logic errors, little relationship to the test they claim to help you prepare for and low quality presentation, to exceptionally well produced products which map closely to the test. Aristotle Circle is at the top end of these companies.

We found ourselves spending a lot of time on the phone explaining to parents that "Yes, there are test specific workbooks," but "No, we do not carry them," and then explaining why. To save ourselves that time we started carrying Aristotle Circle's practice tests and workbooks.

We invite you to read the following comments from reviewers and make your own decision. These comments are more applicable to the full scale IQ tests - WPPSI/ERB, WISC and Stanford-Binet than to group administered screening tests like the OLSAT or NNAT. In the former case a tester who thinks that a child has had targeted preparation may refuse to proceed with testing or make a note in the report. Targeted preparation is discouraged for group administered multiple choice tests. It is expressly against the test protocol for individually administered IQ tests.

If you want to "prepare" your child in a way that doesn't raise ethical concerns we offer many product suggestions. Browse within our Directory of Tests or click on the name of the test you are interested in the navigation menu to the left of this page.

External Reviewer's Comments

DON'T DO IT- Will invalidate results
Bought this book for my daughter as she was curious and a little anxious about the test. We looked through it for about twenty minutes and then put it away, but then during the test administration she mentioned to the tester that she had practiced for it, and the tester noticed she seemed familiar with the instructions. You are not supposed to prepare for the test, so the tester was obligated to put the fact that my daughter had been prepped in her report to the private school to which we were applying, which invalidated her results. It was embarrassing, expensive (she had to take another comparable test later) and counterproductive (can't help but think it prejudices our application and she didn't do as well on the different test.)

There's a lot of criticism in the reviews about giving your child an unfair advantage, but I didn't see anything about invalidating the results. I should have done more research. So unless you're interested in warning your child he/she has to lie about practicing, I would avoid this. I wish I had.

Unethical cheating

The use of these booklets is unethical and invalidates the test results. This is not the equivalent of prepping for the SAT- this is the equivalent of climbing into your child's teacher's window and copying tomorrow's test, then changing a couple of words to make a "study guide." The tests are designed to expose the child to new concepts, so are completely invalid if the child is already familiar with the format. If you are using the test to find out about your child's abilities, then you have wasted your money. If you are using the test to gain admission to a school, this is cheating, which is not a good lesson to teach your child about how to get ahead in life. Psychologists and schools are aware that these test prep kits exist and are on the lookout for signs that a child has been prepped. As a psychologist, I know that the widespread use of these test prep kits forces the test makers to repeatedly revise their tests. They pass this cost along to the psychologists, who must then pass it along to the children that we test. These are important tests with important uses and are not children's toys.

This book is a sad commentary on the modern education system
To start off, I am a psychologist who administers IQ tests to children. I understand why parents want to prep their children for IQ tests. NYC parents enroll their children at the best preschools while they are still in the womb, then prep them for every test along the way (including IQ tests) to gain admission to the "best" schools and ivy league colleges. This, then, assures them of a good job on Wall Street. I understand that the public school system in NYC is so awful that parents go to great lengths to keep their children out of it. It's sad that this appears to be the only route to "success" in NYC.

I hope that parents understand a few important things before prepping their children for IQ tests. First, you are not increasing your child's level of "intelligence," you are merely prepping them for a test. Sure, their score may go up, but it doesn't mean that they are smarter. The "99th percentile" was established using children who had never seen the test before. Those are TRULY genius children. If your child needs weeks of prep to reach the 99th percentile, they are not a genius.

Second, creating unrealistic expectations is not the best path to success. Sure, challenging a child is great. But accept your child for who they are, and they will love you for it. Please don't create an environment where love is contingent upon unreasonable expectations. When you prep your non-gifted child into the "gifted" program, don't be surprised when they are unable to keep up with the work. YOU created a situation in which they were unable to succeed.

What are you really measuring?
As a licensed school psychologist I can tell you that If you prepare to take the WISC-IV using study materials then you will no longer be assessing intelligence. The purpose of the WISC is to measure adaptation to novelty and if you prepare you are compromising the integrity of the test.

Ethically, you are not allowed to prepare for the WISC since it is not an achievement test. It's cheating.